Which Roofing Should You Choose – Metal or Asphalt


When it’s time to install a new roof, people are in a dilemma to choose between metal and asphalt. As both types of roofing are popular these days. In this post, let’s understand the factors of these two popular roofings and differentiate the pros and cons of each to decide which to use.

Metal Vs Asphalt Roofs 

Both the materials have pros and cons depending on the requirement of the customer. Thus, the balance varies according to the different needs. But a few things need to be understood before installing the roof to clear your queries is their difference. 

Metal Roofs 

Metal is light, efficient, and durable. It comes in a range of formats and designs, including shingles, standing seam, wooden shake, and tile. These traits make it stand out from other types of roofing in terms of versatility. Here are a few features that give reasons to install metal roofing.  

Asphalt Roofs

Asphalt shingles are available in a variety in terms of color, texture, and low-cost. This type of roofing is very popular for traditional homes. 

Let’s dig deep into the various factors of each and discuss which is better for your residence or commercial building. 


Metal roofs can be recycled as they are made up of more sustainable choice than asphalt. The quality of blocking heat transmission makes it more energy-efficient. Asphalt, on the other hand, needs to be replaced more frequently. Also, these  


Undoubtedly, quality costs more so as metal roofing does. The asphalt is cheaper to install as compared to metal roofing. But we cannot deny the fact of longevity in both the materials. The life of metal roofing goes from 40 to 70 years and asphalt has 15 to 20 years of age. 


The metal can stand in all the seasons and come with a warranty for 30 to 50 years and lasts for even longer. In the case of asphalt, they are heavy in weight as compared to metals like aluminum. Thus, it is a predicament for one to uplift the weight of such material. For instance, 100 square feet may weigh up to 200 to 500 pounds. 

Ergo, in the meter of durability, metal roofing is extremely durable being water-resistant and lightweight and higher life expectancy. 

However, a problem of dent may occur on metal roofs due to the fall of heavy branches or bad weather. 

TIP: Before buying, discuss the vulnerability concerns with the manufacturers to understand the difference between the types of metal roofing materials. 


Is It Difficult To Replace Asphalt With Metal? 

It is not that difficult though. Inevitably, it needs labor and enough time to accomplish the task. It hardly costs nearly $3 to $5 per square feet so the better option is to hire roofing contractors to get it done perfectly. Brian Pierce has a dedicated team of professionals who not only provide metal roofing and installation effectively but also suggest the best type of roofing according to your house and budget.